Safeguarding Pupil Privacy Using Fencing

 

In today’s world, ensuring the safety and privacy of pupils in schools is a priority for educators and parents alike. While security measures such as CCTV and access control are essential, another crucial aspect often overlooked is safeguarding pupils from external view while they are outdoors. The use of fencing, trees, and other natural barriers in playgrounds plays a key role in providing privacy and protection.

Why Privacy Matters

Playgrounds should be safe spaces where children can play, learn, and interact without fear of external scrutiny or intrusion. Unscreened playgrounds can expose pupils to unwanted attention from passers-by, creating potential safety risks. Maintaining privacy not only enhances security but also fosters a comfortable and stress-free environment where children can fully engage in their activities.

The Role of Fencing

Fencing is one of the most effective ways to safeguard pupils from external view. A well-designed fence acts as both a physical and visual barrier, ensuring that only authorised individuals have access to school premises. Security fencing can also deter trespassers and reduce the risk of external interference. Schools should consider options such as solid fencing, mesh fencing with privacy screens, or a combination of fencing and hedging to provide both security and aesthetic appeal.

Using Trees and Greenery for Natural Screening

Incorporating trees and hedges into school playgrounds not only improves privacy but also enhances the natural environment. Green barriers can provide shade, reduce noise pollution, and create a more pleasant and calming space for children. When selecting trees or shrubs for screening purposes, schools should opt for species that grow densely and require minimal maintenance.

Trees vs Privacy Mesh Security Fencing for Screening?

Both trees and privacy fencing can be effective for safeguarding pupils from external view, but each has its own advantages and considerations:

Mesh Security Privacy Fences 

✔ Immediate coverage – Provides an instant barrier, unlike trees which take time to grow.
✔ Secure and durable – Can be designed to be anti-climb and difficult to breach.
✔ Low maintenance – Requires occasional cleaning or repairs but does not need watering or pruning.
✔ Prevents passing items – The right style of privacy fence, such as solid panels, ensures that no items can be passed through or pupils can come into contact with people outside, enhancing security.
✔ More affordable options – Some cheaper fences with plastic infills are available, though they may need more frequent upkeep.

✖ Less natural – May feel less aesthetically pleasing than greenery.
✖ Potentially expensive – High-quality fencing can be costly.
✖ Cheaper plastic infills – Fences with plastic components often require constant maintenance, as they can become brittle or discoloured over time as seen below.  

Trees & Hedges

✔ Natural and aesthetically pleasing – Blends with the environment and can create a calming atmosphere.
✔ Eco-friendly – Supports biodiversity and improves air quality.
✔ Softens the environment – Reduces noise and wind while providing shade.
✖ Slow to establish – Takes years to grow into a fully effective screen.
✖ Regular maintenance required – Needs trimming, watering, and care.
✖ Seasonal loss of coverage – Deciduous trees lose leaves in winter, reducing privacy.
✖ Potential security risk – Dense foliage can provide cover for unwanted visitors who may attempt to hide and potentially interact with children within school grounds.

Combination Approach using Hedges and Mesh Fencing

A mix of both solutions could be ideal, using fencing for immediate privacy and trees or hedging for long-term enhancement. For example, a solid fence that can handle hedging against it and comes with long guarantees can provide the best of both worlds while minimising security risks. However, be aware that the combination of mesh fences without privacy panels and hedges can have a negative impact on wildlife. Vertical Bar fences and hedges are often a better option for schools.  Read out blog on the dangers of certain types of fencing for wildlife (this is important for schools)

Reducing Noise, Increasing Privacy and Security

An acoustic fence is an option.  An acoustic fence not only reduces external noise, improving concentration for pupils, but also enhances privacy by blocking visibility. Its smooth surface eliminates foot or hand holds, making it difficult to climb. Moreover, it's stronger than a mesh security fence, providing a more secure barrier against unwanted access. This combination of soundproofing, privacy, and security makes it a highly effective choice for schools looking to protect their pupils or students.

An example of a school acoustic fence.  Thank you to Jacksons Fencing for the use of this image.  Their Acoustic Barriers and School Fencing can be found here.

Installing Two Fences 

This situation is more common than you might think and a costly mistake. Often, schools remove a hedge and replace it with a fence, only to realise later that they need more privacy. Alternatively, contractors may build a new school, and once it's in use, the need for privacy becomes apparent.

Typically, this involves installing a mesh security fence, followed by a wooden privacy fence inside it. However, it’s best to avoid this approach, as it doubles the workload and often leads to difficult maintenance, such as weeding and rubbish collection between the fences. Over time, it can also result in an unsightly appearance. 

An example of a double fence line with a security fence installed in front of a timber privacy fence

Retrofitting Privacy to an Existing Mesh Fence

Retrofitting privacy to an existing mesh fence is possible but carries risks. Before proceeding, ensure the mesh fence is of high quality, with no risk of bending or buckling, and verify that the fence posts are sturdy enough to handle the added wind load from the new materials. Proper evaluation is key to ensuring the fence’s integrity and long-term performance.  Read our blog on what to look for in a cheap mesh fence.

Compliance with Safeguarding Standards

Schools have a legal duty to protect pupils from harm, including safeguarding their privacy while on school grounds. The use of fencing and natural screening measures should be aligned with local safeguarding policies and school safety regulations. Regular inspections and maintenance of fencing and planted areas are essential to ensure continued effectiveness.

Pupil Privacy Overview

Safeguarding pupil privacy in playgrounds should be a priority for all schools. By investing in appropriate fencing and natural screening, schools can create a secure environment where children can play and learn without unnecessary exposure to external risks. Implementing these measures not only enhances safety but also supports the overall well-being of pupils, ensuring they can enjoy their school experience in a protected and nurturing setting.