Composite vs Wooden Fences

Choosing the right fence for your property is an important decision, balancing aesthetics, durability, and maintenance requirements. Two popular options are composite and wooden fences, each offering distinct benefits and considerations. In this blog, we’ll compare these materials to help you determine the best fit for your needs.

Material Composition and Appearance

• Wooden Fences: Traditionally made from timber such as pine, cedar, or oak, wooden fences provide a classic, natural look that blends seamlessly with outdoor spaces. They can be painted or stained to match your style preferences.

• Composite Fences: Made from a blend of wood fibres and plastic, composite fences are designed to mimic the appearance of real wood while offering additional benefits in terms of longevity and maintenance. They come in various colours and finishes, some closely resembling natural wood grain.

Durability and Longevity

• Wooden Fences: While wood is a strong material, it is susceptible to rot, warping, and insect damage over time. Regular maintenance, such as staining or sealing, is necessary to extend its lifespan. However, high-quality timber fences with long guarantees can provide lasting durability and often do not require staining or painting.

• Composite Fences: Composite fencing is highly durable and resistant to moisture, insects, and UV damage. It does not rot, warp, or splinter, making it a long-lasting option with minimal upkeep. However, some composite materials may have fire risks, so checking fire resistance ratings is essential. Additionally, cheaper composite fences are known to fade over time and become brittle, reducing their lifespan and aesthetic appeal. Composite fences can also be prone to impact damage, and in some cases, a child kicking a football against the fence could cause cracks or breakage (read our blog on garden fences that can handle a ball kicked against them).

Splits in a cheaper composite fence

Maintenance Requirements

• Wooden Fences: Require periodic staining, painting, or sealing to protect against weathering and pests, unless they have a long guarantee, in which case minimal maintenance is needed.

• Composite Fences: Low maintenance; occasional cleaning with soap and water is usually sufficient to keep them looking new. However, because of their smooth composition, composite fences in damp or shaded areas can be prone to mould and mildew and will need regular cleaning to prevent build-up.

Environmental Impact

• Wooden Fences: Sourced from natural timber, wooden fences can be environmentally friendly if the wood comes from sustainably managed forests. However, chemical treatments and finishes can impact their eco-friendliness.

• Composite Fences: Often made from recycled materials, composite fencing can be an eco-friendly alternative to traditional wood. However, they are not biodegradable, which can be a concern for sustainability-conscious buyers.

Cost Considerations

• Wooden Fences: Generally more affordable upfront compared to composite fencing. However, ongoing maintenance costs can add up over time on cheaper fences. Look for fences that have long guarantees and do not need paining.

• Composite Fences: Higher initial investment but lower long-term costs compared with cheaper timber fences due to reduced maintenance and longer lifespan.  Against higher end timber fences, they are much more expensive and do not have proven guarantees.

Installation Process

• Wooden Fences: Typically easier to install with traditional fencing methods, making it a cost-effective option for DIY enthusiasts.

• Composite Fences: Installation may require specialised fittings and professional expertise, potentially adding to the overall cost.

Which Fence is Right for You?

Choosing between composite and wooden fencing depends on your priorities. If you value a traditional, natural look and are willing to invest in occasional upkeep, high-quality wooden fencing offers timeless appeal. Opt for premium timber with a long guarantee, as it provides durability with minimal maintenance.

Composite fencing has its advantages, particularly when compared to lower-quality wooden options, as it eliminates the need for regular staining or painting. However, when measured against high-quality timber, composite falls short in both aesthetics and longevity.